An Open Letter to Hugh Dancy and Bryan Fuller

Dear Messrs. Dancy and Fuller,

First off, let me start by saying I’m a big fan. I’m a morbid little monkey, and I’m a member of your surprise demographic – young women. I think Hannibal is beautifully shot, beautifully acted, and keeps me guessing. It’s darker than most network TV is these days, and I’m okay with that. I think we have to investigate the darkness of the soul in order to understand it.

But I’m also something else that you might want to know about. I’m autistic.

My original diagnosis was Asperger’s syndrome, but since the DSM V came out, autistic people have all been lumped into one Autism Spectrum Disorder category. Autism is a spectrum, so that makes sense – just because someone can talk, or type, or drive doesn’t mean that they’re ‘not autistic’. It means they’re a different flavor of autistic, so to speak. Personally, I can talk most days. I can type, as you can see. I’m still autistic. I still have non-verbal days; I still have difficulty reading social cues, I still have a near total-inability to read people’s facial expressions. I still need a little boost most days from people who are patient and understanding.

You should know that there’s a lot of misinformation out there, about autism, about autistics and their lives. And both of you have said some things that lead me to believe that you’re slightly misinformed.

Mr. Dancy. You’ve played someone with Asperger’s before – though the script for Adam was, in a word, problematic. When I read your interviews, also, I’m struck by your language. About Adam lacking empathy. About Adam being innocent and childlike and naive. I definitely appreciate that you made a point of saying Adam doesn’t represent all autistic people – but the thing that may be hard to grasp for someone who isn’t actually on the spectrum is that everyone else will think he does. Even today, when I tell someone I’m autistic, I get “Oh, like Sheldon (Cooper, from The Big Bang Theory)!” Or, yes, “Oh, like Adam!”

Except I’m not like Adam. While people like Adam exist, so do people like me. I know I have difficulties, and yes, sometimes I need help, but autistics can be whole people. Or they can be damaged in different ways. Like Will.

But yes. You commented at one point that you didn’t have to worry about bringing things to the role “like empathy and connection.” Or, discussing Will, you once said that Will has consciously adopted the “behaviors of people on the autistic spectrum” to protect himself.

Mr. Fuller, you once said that Will has the “opposite of Asperger’s.

I find both of those statements to be extremely odd things to say. Weird turns of phrase.

hann4Mr. Dancy, your interviews show that you have some insight into us. That’s why I’m so confused by your statement. Why would anyone ‘adopt the behaviors of people on the autistic spectrum’ if it wasn’t to protect themselves? We adopt these behaviors to protect ourselves. We’re autistic, and the world is not. It’s simply safer to be shy and reserved. It’s scary to try and maintain constant eye contact. It’s difficult to know when to speak, what to say. But I can’t imagine a neurotypical deciding to adopt these behaviors. Neurotypicals don’t often feel so threatened. Even with what Will has gone through, even what difficulties he already has in his past, his coping mechanisms wouldn’t be autistic unless he was autistic.

Why must you distance Will Graham from us? Especially if you understand that not everyone is like Adam, if you understand that there are absolutely autistics like Will? Intelligent, intuitive, crashingly empathetic? For heaven’s sake, Will stims.

And Mr. Fuller. What exactly is the “opposite of Asperger’s” in your mind? It certainly isn’t having a perfect grip on social cues; Will is very socially awkward even with his nearest and dearest. Do you mean that it’s a surfeit of empathy? So much empathy that you don’t know what to do with it, that you’re terrified that you can identify and even sympathize with people who do terrible things?

It is the very biggest myth about us, that we do not have empathy for other living souls. And it is the most pernicious.

There are some autistics who do not feel empathy. That much is true.

But there are many more who do. Who feel empathy in buckets, in rivers. We just don’t feel it in the same way you do. We have if anything too much affective empathy and not enough cognitive empathy.

My cousin passed away two years ago, from leukemia. She was 33 and it took her within a month – she was in remission, then suddenly she wasn’t, and suddenly she was gone. I didn’t cry for months – not because I didn’t miss her. Not because I didn’t feel the loss. It was because suddenly she Wasn’t Around Anymore, and I didn’t know how to do anything without her there. I had to relearn how to talk to some members of my family – my cousin used to be my translator, so to speak, instructing me on when I might have missed something. I had to look in other places for inspiration, for strength – she had gained a lot of weight and instead of hiding from the world, she took it head-on, daring it to mock her. I couldn’t shed tears because other steps had to be in place first. But someone looking at me would have found me cold, because I didn’t immediately gnash my teeth and rend my clothes. I still miss her, but now everyone has moved on.

Many of us are hypersensitive to external stimuli – light, sound, smell. But many of us are just as hypersensitive to emotion. Someone a little angry makes many of us coil in terror. When someone has died, we can feel it so intensely that we can’t scream and cry; we’re locked into a place where all we can do is lie blinking at the wall. Autism isn’t about lack of feeling for most. It’s about feeling so much, so fast, so sharply that we can’t fit the mold. We are overwhelmed. We retreat into our heads, and outside interaction and influence can be seen as problematic or even dangerous.

Now who might that remind you of?

If you’ve made a conscious, artistic choice to say Will isn’t autistic, Mr. Dancy, I respect that. But right now I think you think he isn’t autistic because you don’t know what we are. Or refuse to listen. You think empathy is incompatible with autism, and I and thousands – even millions – of other autistic adults and children are here to tell you it is not.

Mr. Fuller, the same for you. If you’ve made a choice that Will isn’t autistic for any other reason, that’s okay, too. But if you rule out autism because you think Will has too much empathy, you are misinformed. And I beg you to learn more.

aperitif 3

Because when I watched “Apéritif” for the first time, and saw Will? When I saw how he carried himself, how he avoided eye contact? When he looked at Alana with real gratitude because she was Known, she was Safe? When he went home to his dogs and surrounded himself with unconditional love, beings who would not judge him? When I saw the hand twitches, the movement of his arms? When I heard Will being described as having so much empathy it overwhelmed him? When I thought there might be someone just like me on network television, unapologetic and simply Autistic?

I cried. With joy.

Think about that.



  1. Love this. THANK YOU. This is beautifully written. The stereotypes and stigmas are SO FRUSTRATING, and our media is not very helpful. Take care.

    PS: did you email this letter to Mr Darcy & Mr Fuller? I certainly would! It can’t be too tough to find their public email addy’s.

    1. Tweeted Bryan Fuller (Hugh doesn’t have one afaik) and I’m going to snail mail it. I wasn’t aware they were reachable via e-mail at all.

  2. “But right now I think you think he isn’t autistic because you don’t know what we are.”

    I see this SO often in media.

    And it is SO maddening, the frequency with which autistic people are accused of trivializing what autism is, particularly if we present, superficially, as an aspie or someone’s idea of “high-functioning,” by seeing ourselves in popular characters… But it’s not us, it’s their writers, who are doing the trivializing when they dangle a decent portrayal of *what autism actually looks like* in a lot of people…and then admit to the tease and go “Ha ha, no he’s not!”

    1. I just figured that if someone makes an artistic choice to say their character isn’t autistic, that’s their right. But if that artistic choice is being made due to misinformation – as I suspect this one might be – then the right information should be provided. And I don’t know if you watch Hannibal, but Will reads as staggeringly autistic to me.

      The whole idea that autistics in pop culture are often white male Aspies is an entirely different problematic trope, but for now, I wanted to write this just because I saw someone on TV who was like me, and I wanted to know why that’s apparently not okay.

  3. I’m not autistic. I have no direct experience whatsoever.

    But this post bowled me over. And it’s down to your honest writing voice, Cara.

    I found you when researching for a new post of mine. I’d love to get your approval before publishing.

    My email is

    Hope to hear from you soon.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s